2003年01月15日 水曜日

Zen at War

by Justin Hall

Books, Japan Abroad, Politics

Zen Buddhism is an aspect of Japanese culture foreigners frequently romanticize and seldom understand. There are the ideals of Zen - consciousness, compassion, detachment - epitomized by the likes of Ikkyu, translated by D.T. Suzuki, evangelized by Kerouac and the Beat poets, and popularized by a series of "Zen and the Art of..." books. Divorced of its origins and context, "zen" has come to connote a guiding principle or a design sensibility - things that are plain, peaceful and calmness-inducing.

But Zen is an organized religion, and, as it turns out, a political entitity. Idealized western views of Zen Buddhism have been sharply questioned recently, as the strong links between the Japanese Imperial war machine and the church of Zen have come to light.

According to an 11 January article in the New York Times: Meditating on War and Guilt, Zen Says It's Sorry, one of the largest Zen temples in Tokyo issued a public apology for their behaviour during World War II sixteen days after the 9/11 terrorist attacks on the United States.
cover
The piece observes: "the leaders of one of the largest denominations in Japan have remorsefully compared their former religious fanaticism during Japan's brutal expansionism in the 1930's and 40's to today's murderously militant Islamists."

This was due primarily to the efforts of Brian Victoria, a former Methodist missionary who became a Zen priest and historian. His books Zen at War and the forthcoming Zen War Stories traces the history of jingoistic Zen. (Initially discovered on Plastic.com: Zen and the Art of War.)

Posted by Justin Hall at 2003年01月15日 02:25

Comments

Here's a bit of an <a href="http://www.abc.net.au/rn/relig/spirit/stories/s69405.htm">interview/transcript of a television appearance with Brian Victoria</a> where he describes some of his research and his views.

Is this not a tad silly? Invariably a state that goes to war has turned to the predominant (or a predominant) national religion and enlists it's institutions in the propagation of it's position. Preachers peddle in propaganda; who better to brainwash the masses.

WWII - American and British pastors were all about "our boys!". In Germany at the time they stayed pretty quiet. I see two possible reasons: the state was doing a pretty heavy duty job at propaganda and the religious were getting ready for the worst.

In today's America, they don't need religion or state sanctioned propaganda: they have the news media, Hollywood and advertisers for that!

My point being: I think it'd be far more imteresting and important to talk about what Zen *is* (insofar as language can do that.. which it I fear it can't), then to pick apart it's role in japanese imperial fascism.


Then again, could be interesting. I just don't liek the way these things set themselves as hallmarks. Especially the mention of 9/11 is irksome.

Sorry for the verbosity. ;)

3- Mopet

Why do not I see me posts???



Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Remember Me?
URL
Preview